Cllr Mark Johnston now sits as an independent on East Surrey Council. He says a call-in backed by 14 councillors was blocked before the decision took effect.
One of Reigate’s two councillors on East Surrey Council has left his party group over the move of Reigate Priory Junior School to Woodhatch Place. Cllr Mark Johnston, a Liberal Democrat, will now sit as an independent on the new council.
He announced it on Monday 16 November, in a post on the Reigate Priory News campaign newsletter that reproduces his email to every East Surrey councillor (Woodhatch school-move scandal, 16 November).
“Earlier today I resigned from my party group on East Surrey Council,” he wrote. “I will remain a councillor but sit as an independent.”
He said he does not plan to leave his party, or the Liberal Democrat group on Reigate and Banstead Borough Council, where he is also a councillor.
Why he says he quit
The move was cleared by the shadow council’s executive on 27 October, when it gave Surrey County Council consent to award the £31 million building contract. We reported that decision at the time.
Cllr Johnston wrote that, in his view, the executive “acted hastily” in granting that consent. He named two executive members, Cllrs Ashley Tilling and Claire Malcomson, as having spoken and voted against it.
He also said councillors had tried to have the decision reviewed:
- he and Cllr Mike Robinson, Reigate’s other councillor on East Surrey Council, asked for a call-in, which sends a decision to the scrutiny committee before it takes effect
- he said 14 councillors in all backed the request
- he said an “administrative decision” then blocked scrutiny, and called that decision “defective”
His post does not say when the call-in was lodged or what reason was given for refusing it.
The shadow authority’s own published record shows the decision took effect on 5 November (notice of decisions, 27 October). No scrutiny meeting on it appears on the authority’s committee site.
The council’s case
The minutes of the 27 October meeting set out why the executive went ahead. They record that:
- the executive’s role under the government’s Section 24 direction was limited to granting or withholding consent for the contract
- the school move itself had already been decided by Surrey County Council, which is the education authority until April
- the interim Section 151 officer warned that withholding consent “could result in substantial abortive costs”
- officers said there was no certainty that Department for Education funding would still be there if the project were delayed or redesigned
In closing, the Leader, Cllr Steve Wotton, said the Woodhatch plan was “the only fully developed and costed scheme available for consideration”, according to the minutes.
Councillors who questioned the plan raised falling pupil forecasts, traffic and air quality, and the future of the Grade I listed Priory building, according to the same minutes.
The petition and the questions
A petition on change.org, started on 2 November, urges East Surrey Council to reconsider its consent. Cllrs Johnston and Robinson said more than 200 people signed it on its first afternoon (New Petition: Save Priory School!, 2 November).
The move also came up at East Surrey Council’s meeting at Woodhatch on Wednesday 18 November, the first to take public questions, according to the campaign newsletter (Six questions to East Surrey leaders, 17 November). The questions asked about:
- a shuttle bus for pupils if the school moves
- what happens to the Priory building once the school leaves
- why the move should go ahead when birth rates are falling
- the scheme’s value for money against school building costs elsewhere in the South East
The meeting papers sit on Surrey County Council’s committee website, which we could not open on 20 November, so we have not seen the answers.
What it means for you
Nothing changes for families at the school this year. Reigate Priory Junior School stays in Priory Park while the new building goes up.
The consent stands, and Surrey County Council now awards the contract under its own rules. Building is due to start in August 2027, and the new school is due to open in 2029.
East Surrey Council takes over as the education authority for the borough on 1 April 2027. From then, decisions on the school’s future are the new council’s to make.
Have your say