The Executive looks again at selling Horley's High Street car park on 19 November. Scrutiny councillors have asked it to put social rent homes first.

The decision on whether to sell Horley’s High Street car park goes back to the council’s Executive on Thursday 19 November. It is item 4 on the agenda published today.

In September the Executive chose to sell the 86-space car park on the open market, as we reported. Its own officers had advised against that. On 21 October the Overview and Scrutiny Committee voted seven to five to send the decision back.

The committee’s final recommendations are now published in an addendum to the agenda. Each one carries comments from the council’s finance chief, its lawyer and the head of service.

What scrutiny councillors are asking for

The committee asks the Executive to:

  1. choose option 3, a full options appraisal of the site, in preference to the open market sale
  2. consider using the Housing Delivery and Community Assets Reserve to prioritise affordable and social housing
  3. focus on delivering socially rented homes, including by working with a housing association, registered provider or developer
  4. set out the requirements bids would be judged against, if it still goes ahead with a sale
  5. consider ring-fencing any money from a sale for affordable and social housing
  6. report any future decision on the site back to the committee, with the reasons in full

What officers say in reply

Most of the answers are short. Several are worth knowing before the meeting.

  • On the reserve: the council’s Section 151 finance officer says any unspent money in it transfers to East Surrey Council on 1 April 2027. That council would then decide how to use it.
  • On ring-fencing sale money: a receipt is unlikely before the handover, the finance officer says. So spending it would be a matter for East Surrey Council.
  • On social rent homes: the head of service says this is already option 2, a sale by competitive tender to a buyer who will build them. It would also be weighed within an option 3 appraisal.
  • On setting requirements for bids: the council’s lawyer says criteria can be set. But if the deal is more than a plain land sale, a full procurement process may be needed. The head of service says likely tests are affordable housing, viability, certainty of delivery, timetable and the price offered.

The addendum does not say which option officers now recommend. The Executive can keep its September choice or change it.

The three options

Option What it means
1. Conditional open market sale Sell to the highest suitable bidder. Chosen in September, now referred back
2. Sale by competitive tender Sell only to a buyer who will deliver affordable and social rent homes
3. Full options appraisal A detailed study of the site before any decision to sell. Officers’ original preference

Redhill’s Gloucester Road car park, part of the same September decision, is not affected. The call-in only challenged the choice for Horley.

What it means for you

  • The car park stays open. Nothing has been sold. The free first hour at Horley’s council car parks still applies.
  • You can watch the decision. The Executive meets at 7.30pm on Thursday 19 November in the New Council Chamber at Reigate Town Hall. The agenda page links to the webcast.
  • East Surrey Council will inherit whatever is decided when it takes over from Reigate and Banstead on 1 April 2027.